Re: Editorial by Dan Hollifield
Posted: December 20, 2012, 11:09:16 PM
I have a few examples in mind concerning romance in SF.
The first is the Chanur series by C. J. Cherryh. There is a small amount of romance between some of the main characters in the first four books. Some of it is between Captain Pyanfar Chanur and her husband, Khym. The rest of it, mostly just hinted at, is between the human Tully and Hilfy Chanur, with very vague hints about other crewmembers. When I say 'small amount,' it's because the action and intrigue leave very little room for any such, but it does round out the characters a little (and gives Pyanfar and Hilfy something more to fight about).
In the fifth Chanur book, the romantic angle plays a more substantial role. Hilfy is the captain in this one, and while she's trying to get over her thing with Tully, who is now absent, her ship takes on an attractive young male, and trouble slowly builds among the all-female crew, to the point where two of them wind up at odds about it. Everything ends well, though, and I won't spoil it for you.
On to the next example: damn near everything written by Robert A. Heinlein, including his coming-of-age juvenile books (which I still love). Romance was a crucial element in this body of work, helping to define the plot as well as the characters. 'Nuff said.
Last example: my own novel-in-progress, in which romance is important, enough so that I once told a friend, "I'm not a science-fiction writer, I'm a romance writer." I'll get differing opinions on that once I finish the work, I'm sure, but it is a crucial element.
Of course, I've seen quite a few SF stories that didn't bother with romance, and for the most part they worked fine without it.
Whether romance belongs in a SF story or not has to do with the writer's focus. I think it's like any other story element: you can't stick it in there just because you think you should. If it's not a defining feature of the characters and the plot, don't bother with it.
However, if you do see it as important to the story, don't be afraid of it. Well -- TRY not to be. I recall writing a very tender (not pornographic) scene once, and realizing that the only time I'd been more nervous was when I wrote a passage in which I had to kill one of my good guys. I think the common anxiety came from realizing instinctively that both of these events had to be handled with the most extreme sensitivity. I still worry a lot about that; I worry about how much detail to use, and how to portray the feelings of the characters; the balance has to be emotionally powerful and not too crude.
Of course, there are some writers who can get away with having a couple of characters duck into an airlock and f*ck like wildcats for ten minutes between battle scenes. In particular, I'm reminded of Alan Dean Foster, who gets away with it because -- well, that's like everything else in his stories. There's a fight, there's some sex, there's a couple more fights . . . and nothing of any great emotional depth in any of it.
But that ain't romance.
The first is the Chanur series by C. J. Cherryh. There is a small amount of romance between some of the main characters in the first four books. Some of it is between Captain Pyanfar Chanur and her husband, Khym. The rest of it, mostly just hinted at, is between the human Tully and Hilfy Chanur, with very vague hints about other crewmembers. When I say 'small amount,' it's because the action and intrigue leave very little room for any such, but it does round out the characters a little (and gives Pyanfar and Hilfy something more to fight about).
In the fifth Chanur book, the romantic angle plays a more substantial role. Hilfy is the captain in this one, and while she's trying to get over her thing with Tully, who is now absent, her ship takes on an attractive young male, and trouble slowly builds among the all-female crew, to the point where two of them wind up at odds about it. Everything ends well, though, and I won't spoil it for you.
On to the next example: damn near everything written by Robert A. Heinlein, including his coming-of-age juvenile books (which I still love). Romance was a crucial element in this body of work, helping to define the plot as well as the characters. 'Nuff said.
Last example: my own novel-in-progress, in which romance is important, enough so that I once told a friend, "I'm not a science-fiction writer, I'm a romance writer." I'll get differing opinions on that once I finish the work, I'm sure, but it is a crucial element.
Of course, I've seen quite a few SF stories that didn't bother with romance, and for the most part they worked fine without it.
Whether romance belongs in a SF story or not has to do with the writer's focus. I think it's like any other story element: you can't stick it in there just because you think you should. If it's not a defining feature of the characters and the plot, don't bother with it.
However, if you do see it as important to the story, don't be afraid of it. Well -- TRY not to be. I recall writing a very tender (not pornographic) scene once, and realizing that the only time I'd been more nervous was when I wrote a passage in which I had to kill one of my good guys. I think the common anxiety came from realizing instinctively that both of these events had to be handled with the most extreme sensitivity. I still worry a lot about that; I worry about how much detail to use, and how to portray the feelings of the characters; the balance has to be emotionally powerful and not too crude.
Of course, there are some writers who can get away with having a couple of characters duck into an airlock and f*ck like wildcats for ten minutes between battle scenes. In particular, I'm reminded of Alan Dean Foster, who gets away with it because -- well, that's like everything else in his stories. There's a fight, there's some sex, there's a couple more fights . . . and nothing of any great emotional depth in any of it.
But that ain't romance.