Page 1 of 1

Soigné Voyage by George Schaade

Posted: August 12, 2013, 11:54:59 PM
by Lester Curtis
Interesting trick at the end, but it struck me as being just too easy on all the characters. I think the story would have been more interesting without the plot device getting them all off the hook, as it were.

That may have also been the reason that the story seemed to end too quickly for me, as well.

There was a bit of overtelling, here:
"Wait! Wait!" Geoff interrupted. "Slow down. Let me get this straight." He thought for a moment. "You're saying that fifty years ago Max somehow slipped past security to get on the Soigné Voyage where he had an affair with Margaret Conway right under the nose of her husband. When the explosion took place her husband died, Max was frozen, and she survived to give birth to Philip Conway, one of the most influential men in the universe. Is that right?"
stating almost exactly what had just been said just a few paragraphs previously.

Also,
his light brown hair was neatly quaffed.
To which I can't help thinking, "Bartender! There's hair in my drink! A whole lot of it!" Of course, the word the author wanted is "coiffed." Damned homophones, anyway. This word is a little ill-fitted for describing a male, anyway -- the author should have just gone with "Werewolves of London" and said, "his hair was perfect." I don't think there's anything wrong with borrowing a phrase that's that good.

This story does appeal to me in one way, though; I'm a sucker for stories about space legends (I wrote one myself). I wish this one had done a little better job.

Re: Soigné Voyage by George Schaade

Posted: August 14, 2013, 04:54:56 PM
by Robert_Moriyama
davidsonhero wrote:...

Nice catch on quaffed/coifed Lester. Those homophones will get you every time.

John
Oh, no! John and Lester are homophonophobics!

Re: Soigné Voyage by George Schaade

Posted: August 14, 2013, 07:46:38 PM
by Lester Curtis
Robert_Moriyama wrote:
davidsonhero wrote:...

Nice catch on quaffed/coifed Lester. Those homophones will get you every time.

John
Oh, no! John and Lester are homophonophobics!
Well, I don't know about John, but I'm not phobic . . . just -- selective.