But does Naewis qualify as a hero here?
Posted: August 14, 2009, 07:00:09 PM
Perhaps not. Certainly his attempt to fight the shade of the ancient sorceror was futile. I suppose that the fall of Akoon might not have happened if his presence had not emboldened Jalala to enter the tomb, but otherwise, he really doesn't accomplish much here*.
This leads us to the question: does a character need to succeed in some sense at the task he must face in order to be a hero, or do we accept the more Japanese view that the attempt is itself heroic? The Spartans at Thermopylae only succeeded in delaying the Persians rather than defeating them outright, but that was enough for them to "win" -- it allowed enough time for a greater force to be raised, as well as providing a rallying cry (a la "Remember the Alamo", some thousands of miles and years distant).
(*The same has been said about Al Majius in (for example) "A Matter of Pride", where it is Githros's hidden presence that thwarts the final attack.)
This leads us to the question: does a character need to succeed in some sense at the task he must face in order to be a hero, or do we accept the more Japanese view that the attempt is itself heroic? The Spartans at Thermopylae only succeeded in delaying the Persians rather than defeating them outright, but that was enough for them to "win" -- it allowed enough time for a greater force to be raised, as well as providing a rallying cry (a la "Remember the Alamo", some thousands of miles and years distant).
(*The same has been said about Al Majius in (for example) "A Matter of Pride", where it is Githros's hidden presence that thwarts the final attack.)